01/30/2010 (9:27 pm)
BOJ Divided Over Inflation Range Effect, Minutes Show
Bank of Japan board members were divided over how financial markets might interpret their range for price stability in December, minutes show.
Some members said it “might be acceptable” for investors and traders to see the inflation range of up to 2 percent as indicating the duration for maintaining the central bank’s low interest-rate policy, according to minutes of the Dec. 17-18 meeting released today in Tokyo. Another member said the range “wasn’t aimed at the so-called policy duration effect.”
Bank of Japan policy makers this week affirmed their forecasts that consumer prices will keep falling through March 2012, marking a third consecutive year of declines. Keisuke Tsumura, a parliamentary secretary at the Cabinet Office, said yesterday that he assumes the BOJ’s range is “effectively inflation targeting” and indicates the bank is far from ending its accommodative monetary stance.
“Given that the Bank of Japan predicted prices won’t rise for a few more years, it can’t be helped that the range is regarded as some kind of policy commitment,” said Mari Iwashita, chief market economist at Nikko Cordial Securities Inc. in Tokyo.
Japan’s central bank has kept interest rates at 0.1 percent since December 2008 as the country grapples with deflation. Consumer prices excluding fresh food fell 1.3 percent in December from a year earlier, a 10th monthly decline, government figures showed today.
Deflation Spurs Bonds
Bond yields are close to the lowest level this year as signs that deflation will linger underpin demand for government debt. The yield on the benchmark 10-year bond was at 1.315 percent as of the morning close in Tokyo after earlier reaching 1.305 percent, the lowest since Jan. 4.
BOJ policy makers said at last month’s meeting that they consider consumer prices to be stable as long as they stay in a positive range of 2 percent or below over the medium to long term. The board said it “doesn’t tolerate” price declines and the median estimate is about 1 percent.
Kazumasa Iwata, a deputy governor until 2008, speaking at the same event as Tsumura yesterday said the bank’s range is vague and policy makers should clearly state that they consider prices to be stable is 1 percent.
Variety of Risks
Some members said the bank needs to assess a variety of risks when it sets policy, not just price stability. The board should consider factors such as asset prices and imbalances in financial markets, taking a lesson from “the experience of the recent global financial crisis,” the minutes show.
The central bank has specified policy-duration commitments in the past. When it introduced a quantitative-easing policy of pumping cash into the banking system in March 2001, it said the measure would remain until consumer prices stopped falling.
The central bank today also released minutes from a Dec. 1 emergency meeting at which it unveiled a 10 trillion yen ($112 billion) credit program.
At that gathering, the board judged that reducing short- term interest rates would be the most effective way to support the recovery and concluded that a volatile yen poses a threat to the economy, the minutes show.
“Given that the overnight call rate had been virtually at zero percent, encouraging a further decline in interest rates on term instruments in the money market would be most effective” to guide borrowing costs lower, many members said.
Surging Yen
The central bank introduced the facility for commercial lenders after the yen reached a 14-year high against the dollar and Cabinet ministers urged it to step up its fight against deflation. Governor Masaaki Shirakawa has said the bank can lend beyond the limit should demand for the program increase.
“The Bank of Japan still has policy options, and the first choice is probably to increase the size of the loan program or extend the period of lending,” said Kyohei Morita, chief economist at Barclays Capital in Tokyo.
One board member said recent discussions about Japan’s deflation might have “negative effects on household and business confidence” and “intensify the downward pressure on economic activity,” the minutes show.
The government in November declared a state of deflation for the first time in three years, and Finance Minister Naoto Kan has been leading calls for the central bank to do more to stem price declines.
More households are expecting prices to fall over the next year, a central bank survey showed this month. The government’s declaration was a “big factor” in fueling people’s expectations for lower prices, said Izuru Kato, chief market economist at Totan Research Co. in Tokyo.